California Health and Safety Code Section 11355 HSC: Sale Of Substitute Substance

1. Definition and Elements of the Crimesubstitute substance sale

There are situations where a person can be guilty of a drug crime even where no controlled substance was ever involved. Under California Health & Safety Code Section 11355 HSC, it is illegal to sell “substitute substances” or fake drugs. That means the fact that a drug is not authentic would not shield the seller of the substance from criminal liability.

To prove that a defendant is guilty of sale of a substitute substance, a prosecutor must be able to prove following elements:

  1. The defendant agreed, consented, offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell, transport, administer, give, furnish or deliver a controlled substance
  2. AND after doing so, the defendant sold, transported, administered, gave, furnished or delivered a substance in lieu of that controlled substance.

Selling means exchanging the substance for money, services or anything of value. A person transports something if he or she carries or moves it from one location to another, even if the distance is short.

A person administers a substance if he or she applies it directly to the body of another person by injection, or by any other means, or causes the other person to inhale, ingest or otherwise consume the substance.

2. Related Offenses

Similar offenses include the following:

  1. Possession of a Controlled Substance - California Health & Safety Code Section 11350 HSC
  2. Possession, Sales and Transportation of Methamphetamines – California Health & Safety Code Section 11377, 11378 and 11379 HSC
  3. Sales and Transportation of Controlled Substances – California Health & Safety Code Section 11352 HSC
3. Examples

A man is at a music festival when he is approached by a young woman. The woman says that she is looking to buy the drug ecstasy. The man does not have any drugs, so he sells an aspirin to the woman for $20 and tells her that it is ecstasy. The woman is as undercover officer and immediately arrests the man. The pill is booked into evidence and tested at the crime lab, where it is discovered that the pill was in fact harmless aspirin. The man could still be prosecuted for sale of a substitute substance in violation of California Health & Safety Code Section 11355 HSC.

In a similar example, the same man is at the music festival when he is approached by another woman who says “I want to take something that makes me feel good.” The man gives the woman an aspirin pill in exchange for $20 without comment. In this situation the man would probably not be guilty of sale of a substitute substance because there was no explicit initial agreement to sell a controlled substance.

4. Defenses to Sale of a Substitute Substance

This offense is often charged following a sting operation employing numerous undercover operatives. If the undercover officer was too aggressive or persistent in his or her actions and actually pressured the defendant into selling a fake drug, the defendant may be able to raise a valid entrapment defense.

5. Penalties

Sale of a substitute substance is a "wobbler" offense. This means that a prosecutor can charge the case as either a felony or misdemeanor. Prosecutors will evaluate factors such as the criminal history of the defendant and the circumstances of the crime when deciding what level of charges would be appropriate to file. If charged and convicted of a misdemeanor, a defendant can be sentenced to up to a year in jail in addition to expensive court fines. If charged and convicted of a felony, the defendant can be sentenced to up to three years in prison.

6. Criminal Defense for Sale of a Substitute Substance

If you or someone you know have been arrested for or charged with sale of a substitute substance, it is critical that you consult with a Los Angeles Criminal Defense Attorney as soon as possible. As a former Deputy District Attorney with over 14 years of prosecutorial experience, Los Angeles Criminal Defense Lawyer Michael Kraut brings a unique perspective to defending drug cases, including crimes like this. Mr. Kraut is highly respected throughout the court system as an aggressive litigator who fights hard on behalf of his clients.

For more information about sale of a substitute substance, and to schedule your free consultation, contact Los Angeles Criminal Defense Attorney Michael Kraut at the Kraut Law Group located at 6255 Sunset Boulevard, Suite 1480, Los Angeles, CA 90028. Mr. Kraut can be reached 24/7 at 888-334-6344 or 323-464-6453.

Share |
Client Reviews
He gave me the peace of mind that my DUI case was going to be resolved. He fought for what it was needed and helped me by answering all my questions. Mike is not an average attorney. He’s a very experienced, honest and straightforward person that is there for you!
★★★★★
I hired Attorney Mike Kraut and I'm am so happy and grateful that I did! I was arrested for a DUI because my BAC level was over the .08 limit. I ended up getting a wet and reckless instead of a DUI. I still have to do some classes and I'm on probation, but I do not have a DUI on my record. If you have a DUI hire Attorney Kraut, he definitely knows his stuff!
★★★★★
Avvo User
There aren't enough positive words to write about Mike, but let me be clear that this is the only lawyer worth hiring in Los Angeles. Mike is professional, caring, and an absolute champion at winning in court.
★★★★★
Kyle, Avvo User
Mike Kraut is not a typical lawyer. He is a straightforward person with a true heart and a sympathetic ear. He is also smart and connected and he cares about the people who seek out his help. He got my son out of a jam. He did it quickly and painlessly. I recommend Mike Kraut to anyone that needs his services.
Thank you Mike for helping my son.
★★★★★
Mark, Avvo User
Michael Kraut is a rock star lawyer. I was really happy and satisfied with the results I received from Michael and his team. A few months back I was being accused of a serious felony. Mike gave me sound legal advice and worked diligently to clear my name. Mike was great at always keeping me updated and returning calls. Great, great lawyer I cant say enough about this man!
★★★★★
Eric, Google User
How can I express how relieved and pleased I am with Michael's professional abilities to have my Felony brought down to a misdameanor to a possible dismissal with deferment. With his care my life has been turned around and cannot say how helpful he's been not only in my case but life. He, himself has changed how I view criminal lawyers. Thank you so much Michael!
★★★★★
Owen, Google User